by SetsunaKou » Sat Jul 02, 2011 6:30 pm
I'm almost in exactly the same opinion as K2!-sama----in the 60m department, Volks look better but Obitsu are sturdier. Volks are also a bit more realistic in proportion (the necks are wider and shorter, the thighs thicker, etc) Obitsu are more waify in appearance and look.
However, I own many of both kinds and love them all. Since most of my 1/3 dolls are anime characters, they're actually mostly the Obitsu bodies since those are super anime-like. Additionally, DD are a little shorter than 60cm Obitsu. So I make our 'shorter' girls the Volks DDs. ^^ Volks DDs have nicer ankles than Obitsu.
For the heads, I love Volks more---they have the anime head shape down pat. But mostly because I'm a HUGE anime doll fan and maker, and the Volks vinyl heads really are much more beautiful. Obitsu now, has the vinyl realistic market cornered, but Volks the anime! It's so funny that they criss cross! (Volks-more realistic body, more anime heads; Obitsu-more anime body, more realistic heads....ironic!)
The Volks also have the non-eyehole anime head which I adore and have dozens of. They make the perfect template for almost any anime character, even males, because you can 'slim' them down to become more masculine anime style! The Parabox anime heads are nice, but more cutesy than pretty.
Since I'm so picky, I buy the Volks heads for my own dolls, even though they're about $45 each, scalp them, and reroot or wig them, because they really look exactly like the characters.
My sister however, goes with the Parabox anime heads, since most of her favorite characters are the more 'cute' style anyway, and the heads are less than 1/2 price! ($18.50!) They make 'nice' heads but the Volks are definitely more beautiful, profile and head-on.
So since I'm more about aesthetics than poseability, for my own dolls, I buy Volks DD heads and for the bodies----I'm not that particular about which. Whatever is on sale or the right size, I'll use. My guys, using DD heads are all on RS 70cm bodies; some of the girls, using DD heads are on RS 58cm bodies, some are on Obitsu 60cm bodies; and some of my sis' dolls have Parabox anime heads on RS 58cm bodies; Volks DD bodies; BBB 60cm male bodies; Domuya 60cm Male body, etc.
I'll end by saying I love both types of dolls----Volks and Obitsu, for different and for similar reasons! ^^ It just depends on what you'd like to do more. For example, I've used a Volks DD body with a number of resin realistic heads (AoD, Domuya, RS, BBB, etc) and the results are always fantastic!! Volks have a realistic mature body, thicker realistic neck and legs.
The realistic resin heads usually don't look as well on the Obitsu 60cm bodies, because the necks are thinner and the legs really slender (which I love for my anime gals more than the shapely Volks!).
So, if you're going for 'realistic', Volks bodies are better. If you're going for cartoon/anime, the Obitsu bodies are better.
If you're just going for better poseability and sturdiness, the Obitsu are better and more durable, though I find their replaceable joints break sooner---probably because they pose so well and so much. The Volks rarely break for me, but are just always 'loose' and floppy resin-like poseability so maybe there's not much pressure or tension on the joints?
Either way, I think you'll like both types of dolls for their different and yet so similar, styles. ^^
Last edited by
SetsunaKou on Mon Jul 04, 2011 7:00 am, edited 3 times in total.